Mid-Cap Banks: Loan Growth and Value in a Shifting Landscape

The U.S. banking sector is at a crossroads. While large-cap banks like JPMorgan and Bank of America dominate headlines, mid-cap institutions such as Webster Financial (NYSE:WBS) and Pinnacle Financial (NASDAQ:PNFP) are emerging as stealth performers. UBS's recent revisions to earnings forecasts and loan growth expectations have illuminated a compelling investment thesis: mid-cap banks, armed with agile balance sheets and undervalued stocks, are positioned to outpace their larger peers in 2025. Here's why—and how to capitalize on it.

Loan Growth: Mid-Caps Lead, While Large-Caps Lag

UBS's analysis paints a stark contrast between mid-cap and large-cap banks. For 2025, mid-caps are projected to grow loans at a 4.5% annualized rate, driven by institutions like Pinnacle (4.6% Y/Y loan growth in Q1 2025) and Bank OZK (NASDAQ:OZK). In contrast, large-cap peers such as Comerica (NYSE:CMA) have downgraded their outlooks, with Comerica now expecting “roughly flat” loan growth due to macroeconomic uncertainty.

The divergence stems from mid-caps' focus on niche markets and smaller-scale commercial lending. Pinnacle, for instance, has capitalized on its regional footprint in the Southeast, where demand for C&I loans remains robust. Meanwhile, large banks face overcapacity in traditional sectors and slower decision-making, leaving mid-caps to grab market share.

Deposit Beta: A Secret Weapon for Margin Resilience

Deposit beta—the rate at which banks can adjust deposit costs in response to rate cuts—is a critical factor in net interest margin (NIM) preservation. UBS notes that mid-cap banks have an average deposit beta of 53%, meaning their cost of deposits rises or falls at about half the pace of interest rate changes. This asymmetry is a lifeline as the Fed pivots to rate cuts.

Webster Financial exemplifies this advantage. With a 3.39% NIM in Q4 2024 (driven by deposit repricing and spread improvements), the bank's conservative balance sheet and strong spot beta allow it to outperform peers. UBS's upward revision of Webster's 2025 EPS by 4% reflects this dynamic, while its 2026 estimates remain stable—a stark contrast to Comerica, whose 2026 EPS is still 10% below consensus.

Valuation: Undervalued Mid-Caps vs. Overpriced Large Banks

The GF Value metrics and analyst consensus paint a clear picture: mid-caps are trading at discounts to their intrinsic worth. Webster's InvestingPro Fair Value estimate suggests it's undervalued by over 20%, while Pinnacle's strong capital ratios (Common Equity Tier 1 at 18.86%) and low NPLs provide a safety net for investors.

In contrast, large-cap banks are overvalued relative to their risk profiles. For instance, Bank of America's stock has surged on optimism about loan growth, yet its 2.8% NIM is below mid-cap peers. Mid-caps' superior NIMs and lower valuation multiples create a compelling risk-reward trade.

Catalysts for Re-Rating: Regulatory Relief and Capital Flexibility

A quiet but significant tailwind for mid-caps is the potential relaxation of regulatory thresholds. UBS highlights that banks nearing the $100 billion asset threshold—like Webster, which is approaching this mark—could gain flexibility if the Federal Reserve revises its Large Financial Institution (LFI) rules. This would reduce compliance costs and free up capital for growth.

Meanwhile, mid-caps' focus on niche lending and cost discipline further differentiates them. Pinnacle's Q1 2025 net income rose 5.4% despite seasonal deposit headwinds, while its expense growth (13%) was offset by NIM expansion. Such resilience is rare in an industry where large banks are slashing costs aggressively.

Investment Strategy: Target Undervalued Mid-Caps with NII Drivers

The path forward is clear: focus on mid-cap banks with strong NII drivers, deposit beta advantages, and valuation discounts. Key picks include:
1. Webster Financial (WBS): Buy at current levels ($60s) with a $68 price target (RBC) and a 3.39% NIM. Its regulatory flexibility and dividend history (38 years) make it a cornerstone holding.
2. Pinnacle Financial (PNFP): Target $100+, supported by 4.6% loan growth and a 3.92% NIM. Its capital strength and low risk profile justify premium multiples.
3. Avoid Large-Caps with Stagnant NIMs: Institutions like Comerica (CMA) or First Horizon (FHN) face structural headwinds and should be sidelined until NIMs stabilize.

Conclusion: Mid-Caps Are the Banks of the Future

The mid-cap banking sector is a mosaic of undervalued assets, disciplined management, and growth catalysts. UBS's analysis underscores that loan growth, deposit beta, and regulatory tailwinds are aligning to favor these institutions. For investors, the time to act is now—before consensus catches up.

Final Take: Mid-cap banks like WBS and PNFP offer a rare combination of value and growth. Pair these with a selective approach to avoid overvalued large-caps, and you'll position your portfolio to thrive in 2025's evolving banking landscape.

—
This analysis synthesizes UBS's research and public financial data as of July 2025. Always conduct due diligence and consult a financial advisor before making investment decisions.