The Menendez Case is Back—and It’s Time to Bet on These True Crime Powerhouses

The 1996 Menendez murder case has resurfaced with a vengeance, and this isn’t just a courtroom curiosity—it’s a goldmine for media companies with deep true-crime libraries. From streaming docuseries to viral social media debates, the public’s appetite for high-stakes legal drama is hitting a fever pitch. This isn’t a one-off trend; it’s a recurring revenue engine for content producers. Here’s why you need to act now.

The Menendez Case: A Case Study in Cyclical Interest

The Menendez brothers’ cold-case resurgence in 2025—driven by Netflix’s High-Stakes Verdicts and documentaries like Bloodlines: The Menendez Paradox—proves that true crime is a perpetual motion machine. Every decade, these cases resurface with fresh angles: new evidence, cultural reinterpretations, or technological advancements (like AI-driven forensics). This creates recurring revenue streams for platforms that own the rights to these stories.

The streaming series alone drove 12 million viewers in its first month, while social media hashtags like #MenendezRevisited trended globally. For content owners, this isn’t just about one-off subscriptions—it’s about syndication deals, merchandise, and licensing for decades. This is the playbook for undervalued media stocks right now.

The Financial Edge: Why True Crime Content is a Bargain

Let’s cut through the noise and look at the numbers. Here’s where the value lies:

Netflix’s EV/EBITDA of 11.6x reflects its dominance, but WBD’s 1.67x is a screaming deal. Why? WBD’s library includes Investigation Discovery (ID) and true-crime heavyweights like The First 48. Yet its stock trades at a discount due to recent losses. This is a valuation anomaly.

AMC’s Q1 revenues dipped 7% YoY, but its Shudder horror/true-crime streaming arm is a hidden gem. While Netflix spends billions on originals, AMC’s niche content—like The Jinx and Paradise Lost reboots—delivers outsized engagement at lower costs. This is asymmetric value.

The Play: Buy the Undervalued, Sell the Overhyped

1. Warner Bros. Discovery (WBD):
At $9.52/share, WBD’s stock is a bargain bin steal. Its EV/EBITDA of 1.67x is half Netflix’s multiple, yet its true-crime library is unmatched. Analysts project a $12.30 target price—a 29% upside—as Wall Street catches on to its undervalued assets.

2. AMC Networks (AMCX):
AMC’s free cash flow dropped 35% in Q1, but its Shudder platform is the undisputed king of true crime. With a P/E of just 15x (vs. Netflix’s 18x), it’s priced for failure but positioned for success. Buy now before the next cold case frenzy hits.

3. Avoid Overpriced “Must-Haves”:
Netflix’s 11.6x EV/EBITDA leaves little room for error. While it’s a leader, its premium price means investors are already “all in.” This isn’t a buy—it’s a hold for the brave.

Why Now? The True Crime Cycle is Back—and It’s Here to Stay

The Menendez case’s 2025 resurgence isn’t an outlier. Cold cases like the West Memphis Three and Columbus Ohio Murders are being revisited with modern tech, fueling endless content. This isn’t a fad—it’s a structural trend.

Investors who buy true-crime content libraries now get:
- Recurring revenue: Syndication deals, merchandise, and global streaming rights.
- Sentiment leverage: Every trending hashtag boosts subscriptions.
- Low competition: Most media giants are distracted by AI and VR—true crime is their blind spot.

Final Call to Action:

The next true-crime wave is here. Buy WBD at $9.52 and AMC at $… [price redacted for urgency]. These stocks are undervalued, underfollowed, and perfectly positioned to profit from the public’s insatiable hunger for justice. This is your moment—don’t miss it.

Disclosure: The author may hold positions in the mentioned stocks.