Mediobanca and MPS Merger: A Game-Changer for Italian Banking and Shareholder Value

!

The recent consolidation of Italy's banking sector has taken a dramatic turn with Monte dei Paschi di Siena (MPS) securing a controlling stake in Mediobanca through a voluntary public exchange offer. As of September 2025, MPS has acquired 62.3% of Mediobanca's shares, bringing the merger closer to finalization and setting the stage for a potential delisting in 2026. This strategic move, valued at €13.3 billion, is poised to reshape Italy's financial landscape while offering significant implications for shareholder value and broader industry trends.

Strategic Rationale and Synergy Potential

The merger combines MPS's strengths in retail and corporate banking with Mediobanca's expertise in investment banking and wealth management. According to a Florence Daily News report, this union is expected to create a diversified revenue base and enhance profitability through industrial and financial synergies. A key driver of value is the optimization of MPS's €2.9 billion in deferred tax assets (DTAs), which could generate €1.2 billion in net present value for Mediobanca shareholders, according to a KeyValue analysis. The KeyValue analysis also projects double-digit accretion in adjusted earnings per share (EPS) and a sustained 100% dividend payout ratio, preserving capital buffers while rewarding shareholders.

MPS CEO Luigi Lovaglio has framed the deal as a "growth project founded on the union of two Italian excellences," emphasizing the potential to challenge industry leaders like Intesa Sanpaolo and UniCredit, a point noted in the Florence Daily News coverage. The Italian government, a major MPS shareholder, has also played a pivotal role in facilitating the merger, including moves that blocked competing bids such as UniCredit's interest in Banco BPM, as detailed in the KeyValue analysis.

Shareholder Value and Resistance

Despite the strategic benefits, the merger has faced resistance. Mediobanca's board initially rejected the offer as "destructive" and "devoid of industrial rationale," prompting the bank to propose a €4.9 billion shareholder payout plan to bolster its independence, according to The Banker. However, MPS's aggressive bid-offering 2.300 MPS shares per Mediobanca share (a 5.03% premium over its January 2025 closing price, per the KeyValue analysis)-ultimately swayed investors. By October 2025, MPS will submit a list of 15 candidates for Mediobanca's new board, with elections scheduled for October 28, according to a DBRS Morningstar note.

For shareholders, the merger's success hinges on effective integration. While the DTA optimization and EPS accretion are compelling, challenges remain in harmonizing corporate cultures and operational structures. Fitch Ratings has noted that execution risks could impact the realization of synergies, a concern covered in the Florence Daily News piece.

Delisting Timeline and Market Implications

The delisting of Mediobanca, though not yet officially confirmed, is a likely outcome of the merger. Legal mechanisms such as the Sell Out Procedure and Squeeze Out Right could be triggered once MPS acquires 90–95% of shares, as analyzed by DBRS Morningstar. However, as of September 2025, the tender offer has reached 86.3% of shares-short of the mandatory delisting threshold-suggesting that Mediobanca's shares may remain listed on Euronext Milan for now, pending further subscription efforts by MPS.

A delisting would mark a significant shift in Italy's banking sector, consolidating MPS's dominance and reducing market liquidity for Mediobanca shareholders. For investors, this could mean a transition from public market volatility to a more stable, privately integrated entity. However, the lack of a clear 2026 delisting date introduces uncertainty, requiring close monitoring of MPS's progress in acquiring remaining shares.

Broader Banking Consolidation Trends

The MPS-Mediobanca merger is emblematic of a broader wave of consolidation in Italy's fragmented banking sector. Regulatory and political pressures have long pushed for larger, more resilient institutions capable of competing globally. As DBRS Morningstar has observed, this deal aligns with a strategy to create a third major banking group, alongside Intesa Sanpaolo and UniCredit, to enhance systemic stability.

The merger also has implications beyond banking. With Mediobanca holding a 13.1% stake in Assicurazioni Generali, the insurance giant's governance and strategic direction could shift under MPS's influence-a linkage highlighted in The Banker coverage. This interconnectivity underscores the far-reaching impact of financial sector consolidation on Italy's economy.

!

Conclusion

The MPS-Mediobanca merger represents a transformative moment for Italian banking, offering substantial value creation through synergies, DTA optimization, and enhanced competitiveness. While challenges in integration and an uncertain delisting timeline pose risks, the deal's strategic logic and government backing suggest a high probability of success. For shareholders, the key will be monitoring the execution of the merger and the eventual delisting process, which could redefine the landscape of Italian finance by 2026.