Take-Two Interactive: Is GTA VI Justified at 89x P/E?

The stock of Take-Two Interactive Software (TTWO) has long been a rollercoaster for investors, but its current valuation—a forward P/E of 89x based on a projected 2026 earnings per share (EPS) of $2.70—has sparked intense debate. With Grand Theft Auto VI (GTA VI) poised to launch in the fall of 2025 and drive revenue into 2026 and beyond, the question looms: Is the market overpaying for a speculative future event, or is this a justified bet on a gaming titan's next blockbuster?

The Valuation Paradox

Take-Two's trailing twelve-month (TTM) P/E ratio is negative (-9.03), reflecting its recent GAAP net losses, including a $365.5 million loss in Q2 2025. Yet, the forward P/E of 89x assumes a 2026 EPS of $2.70, a figure that excludes any revenue from GTA VI. The game's delayed release to May 2026 means the current valuation is predicated on a conservative 2026 outlook, with the real financial uplift expected in fiscal 2027. Analysts like Roth Capital's Eric Handler note that GTA VI could sell 40 million units in its first year, eclipsing GTA V's 34 million, but such optimism is priced into a stock already trading at 89x a conservative EPS estimate.

Recurring Revenue: A Stabilizing Force?

Take-Two's recurring revenue streams, such as GTA Online's $1.47 billion in Q2 2025 Net Bookings and NBA 2K25's sustained performance, provide some stability. Recurrent consumer spending accounted for 81% of Net Bookings in Q2 2025, a 6% year-over-year increase. However, these metrics alone cannot justify an 89x multiple. The company's mobile division, while growing, has underperformed expectations, and the Red Dead Redemption franchise's 1 million monthly sales, while impressive, pale in comparison to the scale of GTA VI's potential.

Execution Risks: The Shadow Over Optimism

The risks are tangible. Development delays have plagued GTA VI, with the original 2025 release pushed to May 2026. While CEO Strauss Zelnick calls the game a “groundbreaking, blockbuster entertainment experience,” delays erode momentum and investor confidence. Additionally, the gaming industry is increasingly competitive, with titles like Elden Ring and Call of Duty vying for market share. Even if GTA VI meets sales expectations, monetization strategies—such as microtransactions and in-game purchases—could face regulatory or consumer pushback.

The High-Reward Case

For the bold, the 89x multiple becomes a bet on GTA VI's long-term tailwinds. The game's anticipated $10–$15 billion in first-year revenue (based on GTA V's performance) could propel Take-Two's EPS to $9.92 in 2027, as per Roth Capital's projections. A phased release strategy—including a PC version—could extend monetization for years, mimicking GTA V's decade-long dominance. Benchmark analyst Matthew Thornton argues that GTA VI's “multi-year growth catalyst” potential justifies the premium, especially for investors with a 3–5 year horizon.

Investment Considerations

The 89x P/E is a high-risk proposition. It assumes:
1. GTA VI's flawless execution: No further delays, no critical reception issues, and no oversaturation of the AAA gaming market.
2. Recurring revenue continuity: GTA Online and NBA 2K maintain their current momentum.
3. Margin improvements: The company reduces marketing expenses and improves mobile performance.

For risk-tolerant investors, the current price of $231.18 (as of July 18, 2025) could be a compelling entry if they believe in the long-term upside. However, those seeking near-term returns may find the valuation too stretched, particularly as 2026 EPS excludes GTA VI's immediate impact.

Conclusion: A Gamble for the Patient

Take-Two's 89x P/E is a high-stakes bet on a single product. While GTA VI's potential is undeniable, the current valuation assumes a best-case scenario with no margin for error. Investors must weigh the allure of a $40 million unit sale against the risks of delayed execution, competitive pressures, and market volatility. For those with a long-term horizon and a tolerance for speculative plays, TTWO could become a transformative holding. For others, the math remains a cautionary tale of overpaying for a future event.

"""