FICO Plunges 5.96% as Volume Surges 202.89% to $1.26 Billion Ranks 99th in Market Activity Amid Regulatory Scrutiny

On July 31, 2025, Fair Isaac (FICO) closed with a 5.96% decline, trading a volume of $1.26 billion—a 202.89% surge from the previous day—ranking 99th in market activity. The selloff follows heightened scrutiny over its credit scoring methodologies, as CEO Will Lansing defended the company’s pricing strategies during a CNBC interview with Jim Cramer, addressing recent criticisms from the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). Analysts suggest the exchange may have exacerbated short-term volatility, as investors recalibrate expectations amid regulatory pressures.

Market dynamics remained subdued, with broader indices reacting to shifting Federal Reserve policy signals and global tariff uncertainties. However, FICO’s performance was primarily tethered to its recent engagement with regulators. The company’s stance on credit scoring transparency has drawn mixed reactions, with some analysts highlighting potential long-term risks to its market position if regulatory challenges intensify. Liquidity surged for the stock, reflecting both institutional rebalancing and retail interest in volatile sectors.

Historical backtesting of high-volume trading strategies revealed a 166.71% return from 2022 to present when purchasing top-500 volume stocks and holding for one day. This significantly outperformed the benchmark’s 29.18% return, underscoring the efficacy of momentum-driven approaches in capturing liquidity-driven gains. The strategy’s success underscores the interplay between market structure and investor behavior, particularly in high-liquidity environments.