Is Dave & Buster's Turnaround Showing Up in the Q1 Numbers?

Let's cut to the chase: Dave & Buster's (NYSE: PLAY) just reported its Q1 2025 results, and while the top-line numbers aren't exactly fireworks, there's a flicker of hope buried in the details. This isn't just about a “value play” or a “reopening story”—it's about whether management can turn this ship around before the summer blockbuster season hits. Let's dig in.

The Q1 Numbers: A Rocky Start, But Trends Are Improving

First, the bad news: Revenue fell 3.5% year-over-year to $567.7 million, and comparable store sales dropped 8.3%. Net income cratered to $0.62 per share, down from $0.99 in 2024. .

But here's where the story gets interesting: The comparable sales decline narrows month by month. February's 11.9% drop improved to 8.4% in March, 4.3% in April, and just 2.2% in early Q2. That's a sequential rebound of nearly 9 percentage points in five months. Management calls this progress under their “back to basics” strategy—streamlining menus, boosting marketing, and revamping store layouts.

The Turnaround Play: Where's the Proof?

The key question isn't whether sales are down—it's whether the steps taken are working. Let's break down the moves:

1. Store Reimagination: 13 locations were remodeled in Q1, and two new stores opened. Remodeled stores typically see a 10–15% sales lift in their first year. With 234 stores now up from 224, scale matters.
2. Menu Simplification: Slashing underperforming items (think: overpriced artisanal burgers) and focusing on crowd-pleasers like wings and sliders. This should boost margins and customer satisfaction.
3. Game Upgrades: Investing in newer, more immersive arcade games to draw families and millennials. The average guest check at Dave & Buster's is still ~$30, but adding value here could drive repeat visits.

The proof? . The narrowing gap isn't a fluke—it's a sign the operational changes are resonating.

Margins: The Elephant in the Room

Here's the rub: Even with sales improving, margins are under pressure. Adjusted EBITDA fell 14.5% to $136.1 million, and the margin dipped to 24% from 27.1%. Why? Higher occupancy costs and debt servicing ($130–140M in interest this year).

But here's the silver lining: The company is aggressively cutting costs. Store-level operating expenses (excluding rent) dropped to 28.6% of revenue from 31.2% in 2024. Plus, the leverage ratio is 3.1x—manageable, but room to improve.

If sales keep climbing, those margins should stabilize. . The trendline isn't broken—it's just wobbly.

The Balance Sheet: Liquidity Is the Lifeline

Dave & Buster's has $423 million in liquidity, and they're buying back shares ($23.9M in Q1 alone). That's a good sign—management believes in the stock. But with $1.5B in debt, they can't afford another stumble.

The good news? They're not expanding recklessly. Capital spending this year will stay under $220M, and they're prioritizing high-return locations. The “back to basics” strategy isn't just about sales—it's about pruning the fat to free up cash.

The Investment Thesis: Buy the Dip, But Wait for Confirmation

So, is this a buy? Here's the breakdown:

• Bullish Case: Sales are turning, store reimagining is working, and the company has liquidity to weather short-term headwinds. If Q2 sales keep improving, this stock could surge. Historically, when Dave & Buster's showed sequential improvements in same-store sales, a buy-and-hold strategy from earnings release to the next quarter's announcement delivered a 101.28% return from 2020 to 2025, with a 14.52% annualized return (CAGR).
• Bearish Case: Margins stay weak, interest costs eat into profits, and competition (like AMC's new entertainment complexes) siphons off traffic. The same strategy faced significant volatility, with a maximum drawdown of 76.69%, underscoring the risks of such a turnaround play.

My call? Hold for now, but watch the Q2 print. If same-store sales keep tightening (say, sub-1% declines by June), this is a buy at $15–$17 (current price: ~$16). But if the rebound falters, this could be a trap.

.

Final Takeaway: Turnarounds Are Bumpy, But This One's Worth Watching

Dave & Buster's isn't out of the woods yet—margins are still fragile, and execution is key. But the narrowing sales gap isn't noise; it's the first sign that management's strategy is working. For investors with a 12–18 month horizon, this could be a diamond in the rough—if the summer sales numbers keep climbing.

Stay tuned. The next quarter's results could make or break this story.

Disclosure: The author holds no positions in Dave & Buster's or its competitors at the time of writing.