CSX Shares Surge on Activist Pressure as $1.57B Volume Ranks 43rd in Market Activity

On August 19, 2025, CSX Corporation (NASDAQ:CSX) closed with a 1.47% gain, with a trading volume of $1.57 billion, marking a 124.45% surge from the previous day and ranking 43rd in market activity. The stock’s performance coincided with heightened activist investor pressure as Ancora Holdings, a prominent activist investor with over $10 billion in assets, publicly disclosed a letter to CSX’s board demanding immediate action on merger discussions or CEO replacement. Ancora criticized CEO Joe Hinrichs for operational underperformance, citing a deterioration in the operating ratio from 58% to 67% since 2022 and missed opportunities to engage in transcontinental railroad negotiations. The investor group specifically urged CSX to pursue merger talks with BNSF Railway or Canadian Pacific Kansas City to counter competitive threats posed by the proposed Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern $85 billion merger.

Ancora’s letter emphasized regulatory advantages under the Trump administration for simultaneous rail merger approvals and warned of potential proxy contests if Hinrichs remains in leadership. CSX responded by acknowledging investor input but did not commit to specific actions. Analysts remain divided, with Benchmark raising its price target to $40 and BMO Capital downgrading the stock to Market Perform due to merger uncertainties. Meanwhile, CSX is collaborating with Goldman Sachs to evaluate consolidation opportunities, reflecting industry-wide strategic shifts.

The strategy of buying the top 500 stocks by daily trading volume and holding them for one day from 2022 to the present delivered moderate returns, with a 10.5% gain. While the strategy captured some volatility, it also faced significant drawdowns, highlighting the importance of risk management in such a high-turnover approach.