The Confidence Gap: How Retirement Savers Overestimate Their Financial Independence

The American dream of self-reliance extends to retirement planning, where many savers cling to the belief that they can navigate complex investment decisions alone. Yet, a growing body of evidence reveals a stark disconnect between this perceived independence and the reality of financial outcomes. Recent studies underscore a widening gap between retirement savers' confidence in their investment acumen and the tangible benefits of professional guidance, driven by factors like financial literacy, market volatility, and evolving economic pressures.

The Illusion of Preparedness

According to the 2025 Global Retirement Reality Report, 66% of U.S. retirement savers believe they are on track to meet their retirement goals, while only 38% of employers share this confidence in their employees' readiness. This disparity highlights a critical misalignment: savers often overestimate their preparedness, while employers and retirees themselves recognize the fragility of these assumptions. The report also notes that younger workers (aged 18–34) have experienced the largest decline in retirement optimism, reflecting a growing awareness of financial uncertainties such as inflation and healthcare costs.

This confidence gap is further exacerbated by a lack of retirement income literacy. The American College of Financial Services 2023 Retirement Income Literacy Study found that older Americans scored an average of 31% on a retirement literacy quiz, with those holding less than $100,000 in savings more likely to overestimate their preparedness. Meanwhile, individuals who engaged with financial advisors demonstrated significantly higher confidence and financial well-being, suggesting that professional guidance acts as a reality check for self-directed savers.

Market Volatility and the Role of Professional Advice

The past two years have tested even the most optimistic savers. A 2025 Schwab survey revealed that only 27% of participants feel "very confident" making 401(k) investment decisions independently, while confidence nearly doubles to 51% when supported by a financial professional. This shift underscores the value of expert advice during periods of economic instability. For instance, workers who received financial guidance were 79% more likely to adjust their 401(k) portfolios in response to inflation and market volatility, often shifting to more conservative allocations.

The financial outcomes of these decisions are striking. Data from the 2025 Empowering America's Financial Journey report shows that savers who used professionally managed solutions-such as target date funds or managed accounts-saved 45% more and had 125% higher balances compared to those who did not seek advice. These results are particularly pronounced among preretirees, who face complex decisions about Social Security, Medicare, and tax planning. As one BlackRock survey noted, 61% of workers in 2024 believed their financial situation warranted professional advice, up from 55% in 2023.

The Financial Literacy Divide

Financial literacy remains a key determinant of retirement readiness. Research indicates that individuals with higher financial literacy are more likely to set aggressive savings goals, diversify portfolios, and review strategies annually. A 2025 TIAA Institute-GFLEC P-Fin Index found that U.S. adults answered only 49% of financial questions correctly, with Gen Z scoring a mere 38%. This knowledge gap is compounded by demographic disparities: men and college-educated individuals consistently outperform women and those with lower educational attainment in financial literacy assessments.

The consequences of this divide are tangible. A 2023 study by T. Rowe Price, in collaboration with MIT Sloan and Stanford, found that older investors with higher financial literacy were more likely to adjust equity allocations as they neared retirement, optimizing risk-return trade-offs. Conversely, those with limited financial knowledge often underperform, relying on default options or making reactive, emotionally driven decisions during market downturns.

Bridging the Gap: A Call for Education and Access

The data paints a clear picture: while many savers aspire to self-sufficiency, the reality of financial markets and retirement planning demands expertise beyond what most individuals possess. To address this, employers and policymakers must prioritize financial education initiatives, particularly for underrepresented groups. For example, workplace retirement programs that offer low-cost financial advice or digital tools-such as personalized dashboards-can empower savers to make informed decisions without overreliance on intuition.

Moreover, the rising demand for professional guidance suggests a cultural shift. As economic pressures mount, savers are increasingly recognizing the value of advice. The challenge lies in making this guidance accessible and affordable, ensuring that all retirees-regardless of income or education-can bridge the confidence gap between aspiration and reality.

Source

[1] Retirement Savers Lack Confidence Over Investments [https://www.thinkadvisor.com/2025/09/25/retirement-savers-lack-confidence-over-investments-survey/]
[2] 2025 Global Retirement Reality Report: US Snapshot [https://www.ssga.com/us/en/institutional/insights/global-retirement-reality-report/bridging-the-confidence-gap-us-snapshot]
[4] More Workers Are Demanding 401(k) Financial Advice [https://www.napa-net.org/news/2024/7/more-workers-are-demanding-401k-financial-adviceheres-why/]
[5] Schwab: Savers Cut Spending, Keep 401(k) Contributions [https://401kspecialistmag.com/401k-savers-cut-back-on-personal-spending-not-retirement/]
[7] Empowering America's Financial Journey 2025 [https://www.empower.com/the-currency/work/empowering-americas-financial-journey-government-sector-2025]
[8] NEW STUDY REVEALS HOW RETIREMENT SAVERS ... [https://troweprice.gcs-web.com/news-releases/news-release-details/new-study-reveals-how-retirement-savers-investment-preferences]
[9] Financial Literacy and Its Impact on Retirement Planning [https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383882195_Financial_Literacy_and_Its_Impact_on_Retirement_Planning_An_Empirical_Analysis]
[10] How Financially Literate Is America - Key Stats by Age (2025) [https://carry.com/learn/how-financially-literate-is-america-key-stats]
[14] Study Finds That Improving Financial Literacy Supports Retirement Wellness and Confidence [https://www.theamericancollege.edu/knowledge-hub/press/study-finds-that-improving-financial-literacy-supports-retirement-wellness-and-confidence]