American Axle Shares Soar 3.27% on Earnings Beat

American Axle & Manufacturing Holdings (AXL) shares surged 3.27% intraday, reaching their highest level since March 2025, marking a 2.83% increase for the day and a 10.28% gain over the past two days.

The strategy of buying AXL shares after they reached a recent high and holding for 1 week resulted in moderate returns over the past 5 years. The backtest shows a cumulative return of 9.16% per year, with a maximum drawdown of 23.55% from January 1, 2022, to September 30, 2022. The portfolio recovered from this drawdown over an 18-month period. This strategy demonstrated resilience during market downturns, with a recovery period aligning with the 18-month recovery observed in the backtest. While the returns are modest, the strategy showed the ability to hold onto AXL shares through short-term market fluctuations, which is beneficial for investors looking for stability after a price spike.

American Axle's first-quarter earnings exceeded expectations, reporting $0.09 earnings per share compared to the consensus estimate of $0.06. This positive earnings surprise, coupled with the company's revised 2025 guidance, has likely bolstered investor confidence and contributed to the recent stock price rally.

Analysts have given the stock a "Hold" rating with a consensus price target of $6.00, reflecting a mixed outlook on the company's future performance. This rating suggests that while there are positive aspects to the company's financial health, there are also concerns that may limit its upside potential.

Institutional investors have been actively adjusting their stakes in American Axle, with notable increases by Dana Investment Advisors Inc. and American Century Companies Inc. These adjustments can influence stock price dynamics by altering the demand for the company's shares in the market.

Despite the positive earnings surprise, American Axle reported a revenue of $1.41 billion for the quarter, slightly below analyst expectations of $1.43 billion. This revenue figure represents a year-over-year decline of 12.2%, indicating challenges in the company's top-line growth. However, the earnings beat and revised guidance may have overshadowed this revenue shortfall in the eyes of investors.