Symbols

Which one is a better buy: Exxon vs Chevron vs ConocoPhilips?

4/18/2025 01:54am

Aime

The deep research logic is organized as follows: 

Okay, let's tackle this question: which is a better buy among Exxon (XOM), Chevron (CVX), and ConocoPhillips (COP)? The user is interested in the financial sector, particularly mining and financial articles, and uses technical analysis and market sentiment. They're looking for short to medium-term insights, so I need to focus on recent performance, financial metrics, and market sentiment.

First, I'll check the provided references. The user has given a lot of data, so I need to parse through it efficiently. Let's start with the financial metrics from References 1, 2, 4, and 5.

Looking at the latest quarter (2024Q4), Exxon has the highest revenue at $83.43B, followed by Chevron at $52.23B, and COP at $14.74B. However, Exxon's net income is $7.96B, which is lower than Chevron's $3.26B and COP's $2.31B. Wait, that doesn't make sense. Wait, no, the net income numbers are for each company. So Exxon's net income is higher than Chevron and COP. But looking at the growth rates in Reference 2, Exxon's net income growth is -0.71%, while Chevron is +45.3% and COP is -23.31%. So Chevron is growing faster in net income, while Exxon is slightly down. That's interesting.

Diluted EPS: Exxon is $1.72, Chevron $1.84, COP $1.9. But looking at the growth rates, Chevron's EPS grew 50.82%, Exxon's decreased by 9.95%, and COP's decreased by 24.6%. So Chevron is outperforming in EPS growth. 

Valuation metrics from Reference 4: P/E ratios are around 13-14 for all, with COP slightly lower at 12.17. P/S ratios: Exxon 1.32, Chevron 1.19, COP 1.98. So Chevron is cheaper on P/S. Dividend yields: Chevron 5.07%, Exxon 3.69%, COP 3.4%. So Chevron offers a higher yield.

Looking at the analyst ratings and forecasts, Reference 7 and 21-28 mention that both Exxon and Chevron have "Buy" ratings. Exxon's average price target is $125.76 (17.6% upside), while Chevron's is $171.57 (24.4% upside). COP's SWOT analysis in References 16 and 17 highlights its strong free cash flow and low breakeven costs but also mentions underperformance relative to the E&P index.

The user is interested in technical analysis and market sentiment. The recent volatility in oil prices (Reference 38) and the impact of geopolitical events could affect these stocks. Also, the end of Chevron deference (References 11-15) might lead to more regulatory scrutiny, which could impact these companies, but it's unclear how directly.

Considering the user's focus on short to medium-term, the higher EPS growth and dividend yield of Chevron make it more attractive. Exxon's larger size and global presence offer stability, but its lower growth rates and higher valuation (P/S) might be a concern. COP, while having strong fundamentals, is smaller and has faced recent underperformance.

Putting it all together, Chevron seems to offer a better balance of growth, yield, and valuation. Exxon is a safer bet but with less growth potential, and COP is a high-risk, high-reward option with potential in the right market conditions.

Concluding Statement: Based on financial performance, valuation metrics, dividend sustainability, and market sentiment, Chevron (CVX) emerges as the stronger short-to-medium-term buy among Exxon (XOM), Chevron (CVX), and ConocoPhillips (COP). Below is the detailed analysis:

1. Financial Performance & Growth Metrics

Metric	Exxon (XOM)	Chevron (CVX)	ConocoPhillips (COP)
Net Income (2024Q4)	$7.96B	$3.26B	$2.31B
Revenue (2024Q4)	$83.43B	$52.23B	$14.74B
Net Income Growth	-0.71%	+45.3%	-23.31%
Diluted EPS Growth	-9.95%	+50.82%	-24.6%

Chevron leads in growth: CVX outperforms XOM and COP in both net income (+45.3%) and EPS growth (+50.82%), reflecting stronger operational efficiency and cost management.
Exxon’s scale vs. volatility: XOM’s larger revenue ($83.43B vs. CVX’s $52.23B) provides stability but comes with slower growth and margin pressures.
COP’s challenges: Negative growth metrics (-23.31% net income, -24.6% EPS) highlight risks in its smaller, more geographically concentrated portfolio.

1/2

COP, CVX, XOM Total Revenue, Net Income...

2. Valuation & Dividend Appeal

Metric	Exxon (XOM)	Chevron (CVX)	ConocoPhillips (COP)
P/E Ratio	13.73	13.64	12.17
P/S Ratio	1.32	1.19	1.98
Dividend Yield	3.69%	5.07%	3.4%

Chevron’s edge: CVX offers the highest dividend yield (5.07%) and trades at a lower P/S ratio (1.19 vs. XOM’s 1.32), indicating better value relative to sales.
Exxon’s premium: XOM’s higher P/S ratio reflects its integrated business model (upstream/downstream/chemicals), but this also implies higher risk from refining margin volatility.
COP’s valuation: Despite a lower P/E, COP’s higher P/S ratio (1.98) and negative growth metrics make it riskier for short-term investors.

1/2

COP, CVX, XOM Dividend Yield (TTM)

3. Market Sentiment & Analyst Targets

Chevron’s upside: Analysts project a 24.4% upside to CVX’s price target ($171.57), driven by its balanced exposure to oil/gas and strong cash flow generation.
Exxon’s stability: XOM’s 17.6% upside target ($125.76) reflects confidence in its scale and LNG/chemicals growth, but its -9.95% EPS decline raises concerns about execution.
COP’s uncertainty: While COP trades at a discount (P/E of 12.17), its underperformance vs. the E&P index (-13% YTD) and reliance on high-cost regions (e.g., Libya, Malaysia) limit near-term appeal.

4. Technical & Geopolitical Risks

Oil price sensitivity: All three stocks are tied to oil prices, which surged 4.5% post-geopolitical tensions in the Middle East (Reference 38). CVX and XOM benefit more from this due to their diversified portfolios.
Chevron deference repeal: The Supreme Court’s overturning of Chevron deference (Reference 12) could increase regulatory uncertainty, favoring larger, politically agile firms like CVX.

Final Recommendation

Chevron (CVX): Best suited for investors prioritizing growth, yield, and valuation. Its 50.82% EPS growth and 5.07% dividend yield align with the user’s focus on technical momentum and income.
Exxon (XOM): A safer, albeit slower-growing option, ideal for investors seeking exposure to Exxon’s LNG/chemicals segments.
ConocoPhillips (COP): High-risk play with potential in a commodities bull market but lacks near-term catalysts.

Key Takeaway: Chevron’s combination of strong fundamentals, higher yield, and better valuation metrics makes it the most compelling short-to-medium-term buy in this trio. Monitor oil price trends and CVX’s downstream segment performance for confirmation.