SCHX has better potential over 10 years compared to FNDX. Here's the analysis to support this conclusion:
- Consistent Performance: SCHX has shown consistent performance over various time frames, with annualized returns of 24.44% for 1 year, 8.93% for 3 years, 14.72% for 5 years, and 12.61% for 10 years. This indicates a strong and stable track record.
- Comparison with FNDX: FNDX, while offering potential tax-efficiency and disciplined rebalancing, has an annualized return of 12.64% over 10 years1. This is lower than the returns achieved by SCHX over the same period.
- Market Trends: Large-cap stocks have been performing well, with a combined average return of 41% for stocks with a market cap over $1 trillion2. This trend suggests that SCHX, which is also focused on large-cap stocks, could benefit from this favorable market condition.
- Diversification: SCHX's broad index coverage may offer more diversification benefits compared to FNDX, which focuses on a specific set of fundamental factors.
- Recent Performance: SCHX has been performing well, reaching a new 52-week high at $66.34, with a 30-day SEC yield of 1.93%3. This indicates strong recent performance and investor confidence.
- Institutional Interest: SCHX has seen significant institutional investment, with large investors such as Cerity Partners LLC and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. increasing their stakes in the ETF4. This institutional interest can be a sign of confidence in the ETF's performance and future potential.
In conclusion, while both SCHX and FNDX have their own unique investment strategies, SCHX's consistent performance, broader market coverage, recent strong performance, and institutional interest suggest it has a stronger potential over the 10-year horizon.