What trends are visible in HLF's quarterly earnings surprises?

Herbalife's (HLF) quarterly earnings surprises have shown a general downward trend over the past three years, with a few fluctuations. Here's a summary of the key trends: 1. **Consistent Underperformance**: The company has consistently underperformed expectations, with only one quarter reporting a positive earnings surprise (0.28 in Q2 2022). This indicates that Herbalife has struggled to meet market expectations in terms of financial performance. 2. **Decreasing Surprise Values**: The magnitude of the earnings surprises has decreased over time. For instance, the surprise value was 0.22 in Q3 2024, 0.21 in Q4 2022, and 0.14 in Q4 2023. This suggests that while the company has continued to miss expectations, the extent of the shortfall has diminished. 3. **Fluctuations in Performance**: There have been some fluctuations in performance, with a notable low point in Q3 2023, where the company reported a negative earnings surprise of -0.08. However, these fluctuations have not led to significant improvements in performance. 4. **Lack of Consistency**: The company has not shown a consistent pattern of underperformance. For example, Q2 2022, saw a positive surprise, which was followed by a negative surprise in Q3 2022. This lack of consistency makes it difficult to identify a clear trend. |code|Ticker|Name|Date|Revenue Surprise|Revenue Surprise YoY|market_code| |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2022 Q2|1.16E8|744.4444444444445|169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2022 Q3|0|-100|169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2022 Q4|5.1E7|-60.15625|169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2023 Q1|4.2E7||169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2023 Q2|3.4E7|-70.6896551724138|169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2023 Q3|3.1E7||169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2023 Q4|2.5E7|-50.98039215686274|169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2024 Q1|4000000|-90.47619047619048|169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2024 Q2|-4.9E7|-244.11764705882354|169| |HLF|HLF.N|Herbalife|2024 Q3|0|-100|169|